Search Documents

By Ramin Motamed, Reza Mohammadi, Zahra Faeli

Finite element methods can be used to analyze the dynamic responses of soil-foundation-structural systems during earthquakes. Therefore, the validation of finite element models with actual seismic recordings is required to benefit from their use in foundation seismic design. In this paper, the acceleration records from the Hayward-I580/238 bridge in California will be studied. At the HaywardI580/238 bridge, three-component accelerometer recordings from two geotechnical downhole arrays at the surface and depths down to 90 meters were used. Furthermore, from 2011 through 2022, 15 earthquakes were recorded at these downhole arrays ranging from Mw 3.4 to Mw 6. However, this paper focuses on the earthquake events within the range of Mw 3.4 to Mw 4.4. Therefore, this study is limited to earthquakes up to Mw 4.4. In the first part of this study, a free-field model of the Hayward-I580/238 bridge site is built using the OpenSees software. Then, in the second part, a drilled shaft of the HaywardI580/238 bridge is modeled. A comparison of the dynamic responses generated by OpenSees with the recorded data from the geotechnical downhole arrays will be used to validate the free-field model, and the acceleration responses from the free-field model will be applied to the drilled shaft. Then, the behavior of the drilled shaft under the applied seismic forces in terms of different calculated parameters (e.g., displacements, reaction forces, etc.) will be investigated. As a result of this study, despite the absence of actual acceleration recordings, obtaining the responses of the soil layers in various depths is possible using a numerical modeling method. In conclusion, not only OpenSees provides a tool for monitoring drilled shaft behavior during seismic events, it provides a robust tool for future drilled-shafts seismic designs.

Oct 31, 2023

By Taylor Stevenson, Takefumi Takuma, Andrew Rose, Chris DellAringa

The city of Huntington Beach is a coastal community along the Pacific Ocean in Southern California with a series of intracoastal flood channels that run through densely populated residential areas. The Huntington Beach Channel and Talbert Channel Sheet Pile Repair Project was designed to improve flood protection for surrounding Huntington Beach communities. The project consisted of installing over 16,000 linear feet of new steel sheet piles adjacent to existing steel sheet piles that line the sides of both flood control channels. This paper studies the unique project dynamics and constraints, and highlights the capabilities of the press-in piling method for sheet pile installation.

Oct 31, 2023

By Vijaya Rao Parigela, Jason Redgers

A 6m height approach ramp was proposed connecting the new railway line at ground level with the existing, elevated line and facilitating an intersection. The ramp mainly consists of a reinforced concrete box section with rising top elevation following the gradient of about 6 degrees for a total length of 120m. Based on the provided SLS loads, resistance was required for 75 kPa to 280 kPa loading pressures. Soil stabilization using Deep Soil Mixing, DSM technique was chosen as alternative to CFA piled foundations by the client to limit settlements. Generally, soil conditions consisted of a made ground layer comprising of granular and cohesive deposits underlain by boulder clay and the Pennine middle coal measures. The specifications for treatment were based on the Federal Highway Administration Design Manual: Deep Mixing for Embankment and Foundation Support and required improving the strength of the made ground below the reinforced concrete elements to an acceptable stiffness such that the structural and track bed movements are acceptably small, and future settlement is mitigated to less than 20 mm, with a maximum of 10mm occurring following the track installation. Verification testing to prove that design requirements have been achieved included coring and testing of samples, as well as zone load pressure test. As such the design necessitated a grid of 2.0m diameter DSM columns with target UCS strength of 0.75 MPa. A load transfer platform (LTP) of 0.5m thickness enclosing 2 layers of geogrid was provided on the top of the treated ground to enhance and ensure uniform transfer of the loads.

Oct 31, 2023

By Md Kausar Anik, Ramin Motamed, Peiman Zogh

The earthquakes that occurred in New Zealand and Japan in 2010 and 2011 caused significant damage due to liquefaction. Engineers have adopted various ground improvement techniques to reduce the impact of liquefaction-induced damage, and one of these techniques is installing a sheet pile next to the foundation. However, the optimal depth into a non-liquefiable soil layer for having appropriate fixity of the bottom of the sheet pile remains unclear. To address this issue, a series of moderate-scale 1g shake table tests were conducted to evaluate the effective embedment depth of the sheet pile required to mitigate liquefaction-induced foundation settlement. A 1/5 scaled model consisting of three soil layers with varying densities, namely the crust, liquefiable, and dense layers, was prepared. A shallow foundation was placed over the crust layer and a sheet pile at a horizontal distance of 0.625 times the foundation length from the center of the foundation was inserted into the soil at various embedment depths using the press-in technique. The test results indicated that the foundation settlement could be reduced by 62% and 72% when the sheet pile was embedded to 50% and 100% of the dense layer thickness. It was recommended that the sheet pile be embedded at least 50% of the firm stratum thickness to achieve optimal performance.

Oct 31, 2023

By Joe Welna, Lola Moussey

The Minnesota Department of Transportation (MnDOT) evaluated several concepts to minimize flooding of Trunk Highway 35W (TH35W) near downtown Minneapolis. A deep stormwater storage facility (SSF) was selected for final design. Given the constricted project footprint, open trench excavation construction methods were not feasible, and a top-down construction approach using diaphragm walls (d-walls) was utilized. The SSF is located near the edge of a glacial valley containing glacial and alluvial deposits including cobbles and boulders. Categorizing ground conditions was critical in assessing constructability of the SSF and determining project cost. Multiple phases of geotechnical investigation were conducted including geotechnical borings, geophysical surveys, and pump testing. Obstructions (including cobbles and boulders) were encountered at some of the borings conducted and therefore were anticipated to be encountered during construction. As part of development of a project risk register, it was decided by the Owner that the Contractor should assume no obstructions during d-wall construction, and obstructions encountered during construction would be paid using funds allocated in a project risk pool, which was informed by a Geotechnical Data Report (GDR) and Geotechnical Interpretive Report (GIR). The cells of the structure were successfully completed in 2022 with final completion anticipated for the fall of 2023.

Oct 31, 2023

By Cody Telgheder, Mamoun Laraki

The U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) Hanford Site had a multi-decade career of supporting America’s defense system during World War II and the Cold War. A multi-reactor site, DOE Hanford produced plutonium for atomic weapons and steam for generating electricity. In addition, a network of nuclear facilities was built and used to support the research and development process, like 324 Building contained within the Hanford Site’s 300 Area. In 1989, after closing its doors to plutonium production, the DOE, Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), and Washington State Department of Ecology took on a challenging, legally binding accord to clean up the Hanford Site. As part of the final clean-up project within the 300 Area, CH2M Hill Plateau Remediation Company (CHPRC) contracted Apollo Mechanical Contractors who contracted Nicholson Construction Company (Nicholson) to design and construct an underpinning micropile system to support excavation efforts directly underneath the 324 Building “B-Cell” structure which in turn would facilitate the complete removal of the contaminated soils directly beneath the structure. The work was completed in complex and challenging conditions that required an airtight drilling system, two layers of protective clothing, a hood with a Powered Air Purifying Respirator (PAPR), the use of long reach tools, and continuous radiological monitoring. This paper will address the design, construction, and challenges encountered with underpinning a structure within a highly sensitive Category II nuclear environment.

Oct 31, 2023

By Will Frampton, Rachel Salter, Zoe Baldwin, Tim Hampshire

Cementation Skanska were responsible for the design and installation of 200 linear meters of contiguous bored piled retaining wall and approximately 1300 bearing piles for a new commercial arena development in the North of England. Building new retaining walls adjacent to existing infrastructure presents numerous challenges concerning limiting disruption and potential damage to services. The retaining walls formed a partial basement meaning horizontal propping was not practicable. To provide time and cost saving to the project, Cementation Skanska developed a novel, space saving solution to traditional raking temporary propping of the retaining walls. The contiguous wall was propped in the temporary condition by perpendicular secant piled buttresses positioned to avoid the permanent works. The buttresses were constructed from existing ground level simplifying the construction sequence by negating the requirement for additional temporary works associated with conventional propping systems. This paper describes the design and construction of the buttress wall solution, considering retained heights up to 8m, with challenging ground conditions including worked coal seams. The design considered onerous deflection criteria focussing on the services running under the dual carriageway along the East of the site and complex loading conditions from the permanent propping solution resulting in a prop stiffness envelope. The paper will detail the design process for the buttress piles and contiguous piled wall, and the iterative prop stiffness approach utilising Plaxis 2D & Geosolve Wallap. This innovative approach to propping saved the project time and cost by omitting the need for additional temporary works following construction of the wall piles and allowing berms to be removed much earlier. This solution was also considered safer to operatives than raking props. Monitoring was undertaken during the excavation phase of the project and measured deflections were below those predicted during the design process, which could create efficiencies on future projects.

Oct 31, 2023

By Karen Dawson, Qiang Li

Unreinforced displacement augercast piles, or rigid inclusions (RIs), were installed for foundation support of a combined sewer overflow treatment building. The RIs penetrated loose silty sand and soft silt and terminated in medium-dense to dense silty sand, approximately 40 ft below grade. The building houses water-holding basins and level-sensitive weirs and equipment. Strain gage-instrumented static axial load tests and low strain pile integrity tests (PIT) were conducted on the RIs as part of quality control for this technology. Strain gage monitoring continued during the installation of the remaining production RIs, construction of the building, and water preloading of basins and channels within the building. While the composite RI-reinforced ground and load distribution mat system performed as expected for settlement control and was not needed for lateral support, RI fractures as observed by PIT in this project might need to be controlled in other situations. Case history information regarding the subsurface fill and deltaic deposit character, RI installation production rates, RI testing procedures and results, and construction settlement monitoring are presented.

Oct 31, 2023

By Jacob Blake, Dan Dwyer, Tulin Fuselier

The recent renovation of Boston City Hall’s Plaza, one of Boston’s premier public meeting spaces, involved heavy construction and grade changes over the country’s two oldest subway tunnels, built in 1898 and 1902. These tunnels presented unique challenges throughout the course of the design and significant logistical issues that had to be carefully managed during the construction process. Despite these challenges, the renovation of the Boston City Hall Plaza has been a major success. This paper aims to explore the successful outcome of the project, highlighting how effective teamwork and collaboration between Owner, Contractor and Engineer played a crucial role in overcoming the challenges faced during the project. The paper also intends to provide insights on how such collaborative efforts can lead to the achievement of a project's goals, despite the hurdles encountered along the way.

Oct 31, 2023

By Brendan Stepek, Mike Senior, Gary Brill

Norfolk Southern Railway (NS) has mainline rail passing through the foothills of the Blueridge Mountains of Central Virginia. The project site is a 70-foot-high cross valley embankment fill in close proximity to an adjacent stream. The embankment has a history of instability dating back to the 1960’s with both significant track and slope movement and numerous attempted repairs. NS elected to have a comprehensive geotechnical study of the embankment performed, install slope inclinometers to identify sliding planes, and ultimately stabilize the slope. The slope stabilization system included a two-tiered system. The primary and lower slope support consisted of a concrete cap beam with post-tensioned tieback anchors and compression micropiles socketed into sandstone. The secondary and upper slope system consisted of a concrete cap supported by an A-frame layout of tension and compression micropiles in soil. All elements of the stabilization system were designed to allow for construction while the track remained in service without impacting rail operations. This paper will discuss the geotechnical conditions of the site including brief overview of past stabilization attempts, the design of the slope stabilization elements, and a successful construction summary given limited access and close proximity to active rails.

Oct 31, 2023

By John Bryant

As engineers, we must understand all possible failure modes and design structures to avoid or safely accommodate them. For the safety of our communities, we must remember that quality foundation engineering is imperative. These case studies provide insight into the awareness we must have and the adjustments we must make to avoid catastrophic, dangerous, and costly failures.

Oct 31, 2023

By Martin Hudson, Lisheng Shao, Navid Plaseied, Adam Richardson

At a project site in San Diego, California, the hazards of liquefaction and seismically-induced settlement were present, in conjunction with relatively compressible soils that would require a low bearing value for use of spread footings. In addition, the site had variable conditions such that a portion of the site did not exhibit such hazards. Therefore, vibro-replacement stone column ground improvement was chosen to be performed such that the multiple hazards would be mitigated, allowing for use of spread footing foundations for a new building throughout the site. The post-improvement seismic performance of the soils beneath footings was calculated and served as the basis for seismic design for the vibro-stone columns. The post-improvement static performance of the soils beneath footings was evaluated using a modulus test in the field. The results of the modulus test confirmed the design assumptions regarding static settlement. The construction techniques are discussed herein, as are the testing and calculations used to justify the mitigated hazards and compliance with the design criteria.

Oct 31, 2023

By Ramin Motamed, Fahim Bhuiyan

Damage dealt with by some recent major earthquakes has raised concerns among the geotechnical engineering community to delve more into the area of soil liquefaction. As part of research funded by Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research (PEER), a large-scale shake table test on a laminar soil box was carried out at the University of California, San Diego, to investigate the effect of liquefaction-induced ground motion on a shallow foundation. In this study, a 2D numerical finite difference simulation of the baseline test was conducted in FLAC using the PM4Sand plasticity model. Some general behavior of sand layers during liquefaction including generation of excess pore water pressure, development of shear and volumetric strain, and their relative contribution to the total settlement were investigated. The model predicted the average final foundation and free-field settlements to be 21.94 cm (measured value 26.05 cm) and 12.36 cm in heave (measured heave value 1.57 cm) respectively. The shear strain appeared to govern the total settlement during seismic excitation compared to volumetric strain, during strong ground motion, while the latter became more apparent after the ground motion had subsided.

Oct 31, 2023

By Greg Stokkermans, Jim Hansen, Mary Kate Dempsey, Mark Reinders

The City of Toronto is reshaping and revitalizing its waterfront in the largest ongoing urban redevelopment project in North America. The redevelopment includes naturalizing the mouth of the Don River, which has become a source of flooding as the city has been built around it. Constructing a new river valley to alleviate this bottleneck involves multi-staged excavations up to 7 meters below Lake Ontario in permeable alluvial sands. In order to place a protective environmental barrier, these excavations need to be dewatered and require cantilevered earth retention over 6 meters high. This paper highlights the rapid design and construction of a 1.1-kilometer-long, up to 45-meter-deep secant pile cutoff wall that was constructed to support the first phase of excavation and dewatering of the new river valley. The paper discusses the geotechnical investigation and seepage analysis, selection of wall type, verticality criteria requirements, and construction challenges associated with the deep secant pile cutoff wall. Data collected during construction confirmed that the cutoff wall met critical design objectives and allowed for successful construction of the new river valley.

Oct 31, 2023

By Casey D. Shanahan, Dustin Walkenhorst

The Howard Frankland Bridge megaproject consists of a new, 3.2-mile (5.1 km) bridge extending I-275 across Tampa Bay. Two steel sheet pile and combi-wall bulkheads with a total wall length of over 11,000 ft (3350 m) were required to create the land for the new roadway and bridge approaches. A total of 1,287 permanent grouted soil anchors supports the bulkheads, which in some areas retain a 20-ft (6.1 m) tall MSE embankment. Anchors with lengths up to 200 ft (60.1 m) were installed, and project design loads necessitated anchors that varied from 3-strand to 8-strand. The soil conditions at the site were typically loose to dense sands underlain by a thin layer of clay over karstic limestone of variable hardness. Given the magnitude of the design loads, the larger anchors were designed to bond into limestone. Limestone variability along the bulkheads was observed. In some extreme cases, the top of the limestone elevation varied by nearly 100 ft (30.5 m), which created challenges for designing the length for anchors that were required to bond into limestone. Given the proximity to Tampa Bay, most of the work was performed from a barge. Waler systems were installed on the waterside of the sheet piles, so installation and welding work was limited to lower tide stages. The geotechnical contractor designed and installed the anchor and walers systems to fit within the proposed concrete cap. The objective of this paper is to discuss the significant design and installation challenges of the anchor and waler system for this high-profile project.

Oct 31, 2023

By Brian Wilson, Franz-Werner Gerressen, Johannes Reinisch

Specifications for traditional auger mixing methods have made use of the Blade Rotation Number (BRN) to establish acceptable levels of mixing. Cutter Soil Mixing (CSM) has no such established parameter. Previous research has proposed the adoption of an Energetic Mixing Index for CSM and has attempted to establish a basis for this utilizing results from a limited number of panels. This paper reviews the basis of this previous proposal and assesses the applicability of the proposed index utilizing a review of production data from a number of sites in proximity to Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada. Based on the outcome of the review, the paper proposes adoption of a new index for initial field quality control of CSM operations.

Oct 31, 2023

By Kamil Nuzha, Jianchao Li, Bashar S. Qubain

A 52-story high rise building in Philadelphia is constructed adjacent to a 3-story historic structure, supported on a rubble foundation at a depth of 2.4 m (8 ft) below grade. The high rise is supported on a mat foundation at a depth 36 ft below grade with an average service contact pressure of 670 kPa (14 ksf). Evidently, the existing foundation requires underpinning but extra care is necessary to safeguard the historic building. A detailed finite element analysis showed that the mat foundation would settle about 38 mm (1.5 in). Although such settlement would be acceptable for the high rise it would cause intolerable distress to the historic building by dragging down its underpinning. To minimize the settlement impact, an innovative micropile solution was implemented to safely transfer the underpinning load into the underlying mica schist bedrock and prevent the existing building from being overstressed by the mat foundation. The specifics of the micropile pile design and associated details are presented herein. The new building was completed almost two years ago and the adjacent historic building has been functioning well without any signs of distress.

Oct 31, 2023

By Mirza Shafiq Ibrahim, Martin Hudson, Rishabh Singhvi, Saiful Islam

The Landmark Apartment building is a 34-story high-rise constructed in West Los Angeles. The high-rise was constructed within a portion of the footprint of an existing parking structure with four subterranean levels. The foundations of the new high-rise were cast-in-place drilled hole (CIDH) piles in order to limit settlement of the new construction relative to the existing parking structure spread footing foundations. In order to construct within the parking structure, a gloryhole had to be cut in the parking structure at the location of the new high-rise footprint, necessitating temporary bracing of the parking structure basement walls. The temporary bracing had to be accomplished using both tie-back anchors and internal bracing (rakers) in order to provide lateral restraint for the basement wall. The internal bracing required its own set of foundations, including micropiles and tie-back anchors to laterally restrain the micropile caps. The foundation system for the new high-rise had to be split into two major pile caps on either side of the temporary micropile cap foundation for the bracing system, with the temporary micropile cap tie-back anchors threading between the permanent structure drilled shafts. In addition, groundwater was located just beneath the bottom-most slab of the parking structure, requiring dewatering of pile cap excavations. With high groundwater conditions, drilling mud was required to install the CIDH piles. These design challenges were accomplished successfully and meeting the requirements for foundation performance and seismic performance of the structure. The multiple challenges of temporary works also required careful coordination of dewatering, shoring installation, and foundation installation among the various disciplines.

Oct 31, 2023

By John Roxas, Rodrigo Fragachan, Alex Gossen, Jakub Szary

The Gilmore Place development is mixed-use transit-oriented development in Burnaby, British Columbia, Canada. The development replaces the underutilized space surrounding the existing Gilmore SkyTrain Station and overhead SkyTrain guideway that bisects the site with three support piers fully contained within the building footprint. The site includes six combined office and residential towers, including the tallest tower in British Columbia when constructed at 64 stories. Below grade development includes a phased temporary support of excavation. The first phase involves the excavation of a 14,200m2 pit up to depths of 30.5m below street grades removing about 42,475m3 of soil. Support of excavation included 1,229 secant piles and 2,689 strand anchors of high-capacity, achieving working loads of up to 1800kN. Each of the three SkyTrain piers are supported by a single 3.0m diameter caisson. To facilitate excavation below each caisson supported pier and encapsulate them by the base building structure, temporary support measures were developed. Bracing included sets of 22.0m long inclined 610mm diameter x19mm thick steel pipe raker braces connected at the base of each pier and three rows of jackable frames connected to the piers and temporary shoring walls. This shoring system is one of the most challenging shoring systems in Metro Vancouver as the original SkyTrain pier foundations had to be exposed. Secant piles were installed down to bedrock around the existing caissons utilizing a custom low headroom drill rig. A robust automated instrumentation program was established to monitor movements of the shoring wall and SkyTrain infrastructure in real time, and to provide immediate alerts to the design and construction team should movements exceed predetermined thresholds established by the design team. The monitoring program indicated movements of the guideway, station, and supporting piers were below the maximum tolerances during the excavation phase of construction and enabled the continued use of the transportation system without disruption or jeopardizing public safety.

Oct 31, 2023

By Seth Knihtila, Bryce Niekamp, Adam Running

The current home of the Seattle Kraken NHL team is the Climate Pledge Arena in Seattle, Washington. The renovation of the existing 1962 World’s Fair Pavilion transformed the aging and outdated facility into a modern 900,000 square ft., 17,000 seat arena with all modern amenities. Although the existing arena already extended below grade, it included minimal event and amenities space, and did not meet the current needs for a sports and entertainment venue. In order to transform the arena, the site was further excavated to about 60 ft. (18.3 m.) below grade in order to provide additional space and access. The challenge: the existing roof was to remain in place with the majority of the expansion occurring below grade. The existing roof was underpinned on a series of 67 drilled shafts installed with low headroom equipment. In addition, support of the new arena structure required deep foundation support consisting of 117 drilled shafts of varying diameter and depth within the excavation. The primary support of excavation system or shoring system selected was permanent soldier piles and lagging with permanent tiebacks. This installation of the shoring system and excavation had to be completed with the iconic concrete roof, weighing in at 22,000 tons, suspended in place on temporary steel support framing and drilled shafts. The support of excavation system consisted of four elements: the primary perimeter excavation, snorkels, pylon shoring, and the south buttress shoring and support, each of which had their own unique design and construction challenges. In the end, the construction team installed approximately 178,000 square feet of permanent shoring, including 500 soldier piles and 130,000 linear ft. of tiebacks. The performance of the drilled shaft installation was monitored by CSL testing. The performance of the shoring system was monitored by geotechnical instrumentation and performed as predicted in our analysis.

Oct 31, 2023