Search Documents

R. Schuhmann, Jr. (Purdue University)— Fulton and Chipman's results on rate of silica reduction from slags are analogous in many was to the results of Parlee, Seagle, and Schuhmann10 on rate of alumina reduction from alumina crucibles. Both investigations have given comparably low rates of reduction and slow approaches to equilibrium. Accordingly, we may hypothesize that the rate-determining step is the same in both kinds of experiments; that is, oxygen diffusion across the stagnant boundary layer on the liquid-metal side of the interface between the liquid metal and the oxide phase (slag or solid oxide). I suggest that silica reduction involves the following consecutive steps: I) At the slag-metal interface: SiO2(slag) Si+ 20 II) Transport of oxygen from slag-metal to gas-metal interface: a) diffusion across liquid-metal boundary layer at slag-metal interface. b) convection within the body of liquid metal. c) diffusion across boundary layer at metal-gas interface. 111) At the metal-gas interface: C +O- CO (gas) Iv) At the graphite-metal interface: C (graphite) -C At steelmaking temperatures it is reasonable to assume that equilibrium is attained in all three chemical reactions (I, 111, and IV) right at the respective interfaces. Convection within the stirred liquid metal (step IIb) is also rapid. Transport of Si and C should be orders of magnitude easier than transport of 0, because of the relatively high concentrations of Si and C. Accordingly, we might expect the overall reaction rate to be determined by boundary-layer diffusion of oxygen, either IIa or IIc. Fulton and Chipman's demonstration that bubbling CO through the system had no major effect on reaction rate indicates that IIc is not the slowest step. Therefore, it becomes logical to estimate the maximum rate for step IIa and to compare this theoretical estimate with Fulton and Chipman's experimental data. If oxygen diffusion across the liquid metal boundary layer at the slag metal interface (step IIa) is rate-determining, In this equation, dn sio, /dt is the rate of silica reduction in moles per sec,A is the area of slag-metal interface in sq cm, Do is the diffusivity of oxygen in sq cm per sec, 6, is the boundary layer thickness in cm, c,* is the oxygen concentration right at the slag-metal interface in moles per cubic cm, and co is the oxygen concentration in the body of the liquid metal, also in moles per cubic cm. Equilibrium data" on the silicon deoxidation reaction in liquid iron and steel at 1600°C indicate that the oxygen contents of the liquid metal in Fulton and Chipman's experiments at 1600°C probably fell in the range of 0.5 x10-3 x10-3wt pct. That is, the maximum conceivable value of co*-co for the system under consideration was on the order of 10"5 mole oxygen per cubic cm. On the basis of previously published data,1O,11 it is estimated that Do/0 will fall somewhere in the range from 10-3 to 10-1 cm per sec. The surface area A in Fulton and Chipman's experiments was approximately 20 sq cm, and the weight of metal involved was about 500 grams. Combination of all these figures with the above rate equation leads to an estimate that the rate of silica reduction should fall within the range from 0.002 to 0.2 wt pct Si per hr. This estimate is consistent with the experimental data. For example, Fulton and Chipman's Fig. 2 shows a change of about 0.3 pct Si in 10 hr, corresponding to an average rate of 0.03 pct per hr. According to the proposed hypothesis, increasing the temperature will increase the reaction rate ill two ways: 1) by increasing oxygen diffusivity and 2) by increasing the oxygen concentration (oxygen solubility) in the liquid metal. The combination of these two effects accounts for the high value of the observed activation energy. Summarizing, I propose that the rate of silica reduction, like that of the carbon-oxygen reaction, is diffusion controlled and that low oxygen concentration in the liquid metal is the major factor accounting for the very low observed rates of silica reduction. John Chipman (author's reply)—The authors thank Professor Schuhmann for his interesting contribution. His proposed explanation may well prove to be the correct one. There is clearly a need for much further experimental work on this problem, and further research is in progress.

Jan 1, 1961

By AIME AIME

Council. * PRESIDENT OF THE COUNCIL. JAMES F. KEMP NEW YORK, N.Y. (Term expires February, 1913.) VICE-PRESIDENTS OF THE COUNCIL. S. B. CHRISTY BERKELEY, CAL. W. A. LATHROP PHILADELPHIA, PA. GARDNER F. WILLIAMS WASHINGTON, D. C. (Term expires February, 1913.) KARL EILERS NEW YORK, N. Y. WALDEMAR LINDGREN WASHINGTON, D. C. BENJAMIN B. THAYER NEW YORK, N. Y. (Term expires February, 1914.)

Mar 1, 1912

By AIME AIME

COUNCIL.* PRESIDENT OF THE COUNCIL. JAMES F. KEMP : NEW YORK, N. Y. (Term expires February, 1913.) VICE-PRESIDENTS OF THE COUNCIL. S. B. CHRISTY BERKELEY, CAL. W. A. LATHROP PHILADELPHIA, PA. GARDNER F. WILLIAMS WASHINGTON, D. C. (Term expires February, 1913.) KARL EILERS NEW YORK, N. Y. WALDEMAR LINDGREN WASHINGTON, D. C. BENJAMIN B. THAYER NEW YORK, N. Y. (Term expires February, 1914.)

Apr 1, 1912

BRANCH COUNCILS Mining Branch E R Price, Chairman (Coal) Howard A Meyerhoff (Industrial Minerals) J V Beall, Secretary Richard M Foose (Industrial Minerals) Carroll F Hardy (Coal) Frank A Hardlaw (Mining, Geology, and Geophysics) S J Swainson (Minerals Beneficiation) Philip J Shenon (Mining, Geology, and Geophysics) Grover J Holt (Minerals Beneficiation) A C Callen (Mineral Industry Education) C H. Behre, Jr. (Mineral Economics)

Jan 1, 1952

Iowa State College Ames, Iowa Iowa State Mining Society CARL S. NELSON, President NORMAN S. GEIST, Secretary K. A. PHILLIPS, Faculty Sponsor C. G. DRESSER, Counselor University Of Kansas Lawrence, Kansas University of Kansas Student Chapter of A.I.M.E. WALTER CROOK, President EDWARD C. MISHOU, Secretary E. A. STEPHENSON, Faculty Sponsor GEORGE M. FOWLER, Counselor K. A. SPENCER, Counselor .

Jan 1, 1942

President MRS. ROBERT HURSH River Road, Silvermine Norwalk, Conn. First Vice -President MRS. WILLIAM C. SCHNEIDER 45 Wayne Ave. White Plains, N. Y. Second Vice-President MRS. ERNEST H. WOLFES 180 Riverside Drive New York, N. Y. Third Vice-President MRS. JOHN C. BURTON 271 Fox Meadow Road Scarsdale, N. Y. Fourth Vice-President MRS. S. A. IONIDES 379 Marion Street Denver, Colo.

Jan 1, 1941

PRESIDENT W E WRATHER Washington, D C PAST PRESIDENTS Louis S CATES, New York, N Y CLYDE WILLIAMS, Columbus, Ohio VICE PRESIDENTS ' HOLCOMBE J BROWN,' Boston, Mass ROBERT W THOMAS, Ray, Ariz RLE V DAVELER, New York, N Y C HARRY BENEDICT Lake Linden, Mich DONALD H MCLAUCHLIN, San Fiancisco, Calif VICE PRESIDENT AND TREASURER ANDREW FLETCHER New York, N Y

Jan 1, 1952

For the year ending February, 1919 PRESIDENT SIDNEY J. JENNINGS NEW YORK, N. Y. PAST PRESIDENTS L. D. RICKETTS, NEW YORK, N. Y. PHILIP N. MOORE ST. Louis, Mo. FIRST VICE-PRESIDENT C. W. GOODALE, BUTTE, MONT. TREASURER GEORGE C. STONE, NEW YORK, N. Y. SECRETARY EMERITUS ROSSITER W. RAYMOND, NEW YORK, N. Y. SECRETARY BRADLEY STOUGHTON NEW YORK, N. Y.

Jan 11, 1918

For the year ending February, 1918 PRESIDENT SIDNEY J. JENNINGS, NEW YORK, N. Y. PAST PRESIDENTS L. D: RICKETTS, ; . , . NEW YORK, N. Y. PHILIP N. MOORE, , ST. Louis, Mo FIRST VICE-PRESIDENT C. W. GOODALE, . . . . BUTTE, MONT. TREASURER GEORGE C. STONE NEW YORK, N. Y. SECRETARY EMERITUS ROSSITER W. RAYMOND,. NEW YORK, N. Y. SECRETARY BRADLEY STOUGHTON NEW YORK, N. Y.

Jan 3, 1918

E. O?C. Acker Jinzoc Adachi Truman H. Aldrich Walter H. Aldridge Anson W. Allen John H. Allen William R. Appleby W. Lawrence Austin W. S. Ayres David Baker John Henry Banks Henry C. Banon Alonzo F. Bardwell Wm de L. Benedict Robert Bentley Andrew A Blair Walter M. Brodie Elwin F. Brown Fredrick Burbidge H.H. Burden Charles Butters

Jan 1, 1941

E. O?C. Acker Jinzoc Adachi Truman H. Aldrich Walter H. Aldridge Anson W. Allen John H. Allen William R. Appleby W. Lawrence Austin W. S. Ayres David Baker John Henry Banks Henry C. Banon Alonzo F. Bardwell Wm de L. Benedict Robert Bentley Andrew A Blair Walter M. Brodie Elwin F. Brown Fredrick Burbidge H.H. Burden Charles Butters

Jan 1, 1942

For the year ending February, 1919 PRESIDENT SIDNEY J. JENNINGS NEW YORK, N. Y. PAST PRESIDENTS L. D. RICKETTS NEW YORK, N. Y. PHILIP N. MOORE ST. Louis, Mo. FIRST VICE-PRESIDENT C. W. GOODALE BUTTE, MONT. TREASURER GEORGE C. STONE, NEW YORK, N. Y. SECRETARY EMERITUS ROSSITER W. RAYMOND, NEW YORK, N. Y. SECRETARY BRADLEY STOUGHTON NEW YORK, N. Y.

Jan 9, 1918

For the year ending February, 1919 PRESIDENT SIDNEY J. JENNINGS NEW YORK, N. Y. PAST PRESIDENTS L. D. RICKETTS NEW YORK, N. Y. PHILIP N. MOORE ST Louis, Mo. FIRST VICE-PRESIDENT C. W. GOODALE BUTTE, MONT. TREASURER GEORGE C. STONE, NEW YORK, N. Y. SECRETARY EMERITUS ROSSITER W. RAYMOND, NEW YORK, N. Y. SECRETARY BRADLEY STOUGHTON NEW YORK, N. Y.

Jan 7, 1918

For the year ending February, 1919 PRESIDENT SIDNEY .J. JENNINGS NEW YORK, N. Y. PAST PRESIDENTS L. D. RICKETTS, NEW YORK, N. Y. PHILIP N. MOORE, ST.Louis, Mo. FIRST VICE-PRESIDENT C. W. GOODALE BUTTE, MONT. TREASURER GEORGE C. STONE, : NEW YORK, N. Y. SECRETARY' EMERITUS ROSSITER W. RAYMOND NEW YORK, N. Y. SECRETARY BRADLEY STOUGHTON, NEW YORK, N. Y.

Jan 10, 1918

COUNCIL.* PRESIDENT OF THE COUNCIL. JAMES F. KEMP NEW YORK, N. Y. (Term expires February, 1913.) VICE-PRESIDENTS OF THE COUNCIL. S. B. CHRISTY BERKELEY, CAL. W. A. LATHROP PHILADELPHIA, PA. GARDNER F. WILLIAMS WASHINGTON, D. C. (Term expires February, 1913.) KARL EILERS NEW YORK, N. Y. WALDEMAR LINDGREN WASHINGTON, D. C. BENJAMIN B. THAYER NEW YORK, N. Y. (Term expires February, 1914.)

Jan 1, 1917

For. the year ending February, 1919 PRESIDENT SIDNEY J. JENNINGS NEW YORK, N. Y. PAST PRESIDENTS L. D. RICKETTS NEW YORK, N. Y. PHILIP N. MOORE, ST. LOUIS, M.O. FIRST VICE-PRESIDENT C. W. GOODALE, BUTTE, MONT. TREASURER GEORGE C. STONE, NEW YORK, N. Y. SECRETARY EMERITUS ROSSITER W. RAYMOND, NEW YORK, N.Y. SECRETARY BRADLEY STOUGHTON NEW YORK, N. Y.

Jan 8, 1918

PRESIDENT L E Young', Pittsburgh, Pa PAST PRESIDENTS Clyde Williams, Columbus, Ohio W. E Wrather, Washington, D C VICE-PRESIDENTS Robert W Thomas', Ray, Ariz C Harry Benedict, Lake Linden, Mich D H McLaughlin, San Francisco, Calif A B Kinzel, New York, N Y Philip Kraft, New York, N Y VICE-PRESIDENT AND TREASURER Andrew Fletcher, New York, N Y

Jan 1, 1949

Executive A R LEDUC, Chairman ARTHUR S DWIGHT R V NORRIS EDWIN LUDLOW E L DEGOLYER Membership J V W REYNDERS, Chairman E L DEGOLYER R M RAYMOND EDGAR RICKARD W Y WESTERVELT Finance WALTER H ALDRIDGE, Chairman GALEN H CLEVENGER J V W REYNDERS Library Chairman JOHN H JANEWAY GEORGE C STONES ROBERT LINTON ALEXANDER C HUMPHRLYS, - BRADLEY STOUGHTON

Jan 1, 1923

INDUSTRIAL MINERALS DIVISION (Nonmetallics) Established as a Division March 15, 1935 Ian Campbell, Chairman Robert C Stephenson, Eastern Vice-Chairman Allen Cole, Southeastern Vice-Chairman David P Hale, Jr, Rocky Mountain Vice-Chairman G H Waterman, Western Vice-Chairman M F Goudge, Canadian Vice-Chairman James Norton, Secretary-Treasurer Mineral Deposits Branch U S Geological Survey Washington 25, D C.

Jan 1, 1952

COMMITTEES. Precious and Base Metals. Charles W. Goodale, Chairman.. L. D. Ricketts, Vice-Chairman Darsie C. Bard, Secretary, Montana State School of Mines, Butte, Mont. Leonard S. Austin, Thomas J. Grier, Willet G. Miller, David W. Brunton, Hennen Jennings, Albert F. Schneider, Theodore B. Comstock, Edmund B. Kirby, George C. Stone, Stanley A. Easton, Charles W. Merrill, Benjamin B. Thayer. Samuel S. Fowler,

Jan 11, 1913